Scorecard Bills

House Bill 601 would provide immunity from civil damages to volunteer security personnel of a religious organization so long as their actions do not constitute gross negligence or wanton or reckless misconduct.

Introduced
In Committee
Crossed Over
Passed
Signed/Enacted/Adopted

Roll Call Vote (House)

Party

Yea

Nay

Not Voting

Roll Call Vote (Senate)

Party

Yea

Nay

Not Voting

Compare District

Last Action

Reported Signed by Governor on April 1, 2024 Session Law Chapter 256 Effective: 07/01/2024

Analysis

1 Idaho Freedom Analysis

Supported (89)

Senate

Phil Hart

ID002

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A+

Freedom Index

97.5%

House

Elaine Price

ID004

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A+

Freedom Index

96.3%

A+

Spending Index

100.0%

House

Tony Wisniewski

ID005

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

95.7%

Senate

Scott Herndon

ID001

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

94.9%

House

Heather Scott

ID002

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

94.5%

A+

Spending Index

100.0%

House

Dale Hawkins

ID002

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A-

Freedom Index

93.9%

A+

Spending Index

100.0%

House

Jacyn Gallagher

ID009

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A-

Freedom Index

92.0%

House

Tina Lambert

ID023

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A-

Freedom Index

91.7%

Senate

Brian Lenney

ID013

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A-

Freedom Index

90.8%

House

Josh Tanner

ID014

A+

Education Index

100.0%

B+

Freedom Index

89.9%

Senate

Cindy Carlson

ID007

A-

Education Index

92.9%

B+

Freedom Index

89.8%

House

Mike Kingsley

ID007

A-

Education Index

91.7%

B+

Freedom Index

89.6%

Senate

Tammy Nichols

ID010

A+

Education Index

100.0%

B+

Freedom Index

89.2%

Senate

Glenneda Zuiderveld

ID024

A+

Education Index

100.0%

B+

Freedom Index

88.5%

House

Joe Alfieri

ID004

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

85.9%

Senate

Ben Toews

ID004

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

85.4%

House

Ron Mendive

ID005

Education Index

75.0%

B-

Freedom Index

83.4%

House

Vito Barbieri

ID003

A+

Education Index

100.0%

B-

Freedom Index

82.8%

House

Bruce Skaug

ID010

A+

Education Index

100.0%

C+

Freedom Index

78.5%

House

Julianne Young

ID030

Education Index

75.0%

C+

Freedom Index

78.2%

Senate

Chris Trakel

ID011

A+

Education Index

100.0%

C+

Freedom Index

77.1%

House

Jordan Redman

ID003

A+

Education Index

100.0%

C+

Freedom Index

77.0%

Senate

Doug Okuniewicz

ID003

A+

Education Index

100.0%

C+

Freedom Index

76.4%

House

Kevin Andrus

ID035

B-

Education Index

83.3%

Freedom Index

75.5%

House

Brent Crane

ID013

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

75.1%

House

Barbara Ehardt

ID033

Education Index

95.8%

C-

Freedom Index

71.8%

Senate

Carl Bjerke

ID005

A+

Education Index

100.0%

C-

Freedom Index

71.7%

House

Charlie Shepherd

ID007

A-

Education Index

91.7%

C-

Freedom Index

70.2%

House

Jaron Crane

ID012

A+

Education Index

100.0%

D+

Freedom Index

69.9%

House

Sage Dixon

ID001

A-

Education Index

91.7%

D+

Freedom Index

69.3%

House

David Cannon

ID030

C-

Education Index

70.8%

D+

Freedom Index

67.2%

House

Ted Hill

ID014

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

65.0%

House

Jason Monks

ID022

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

64.4%

House

Joe Palmer

ID020

B-

Education Index

83.3%

Freedom Index

64.4%

House

Jeff Ehlers

ID021

A+

Education Index

100.0%

D-

Freedom Index

63.2%

House

Brandon Mitchell

ID006

A+

Education Index

100.0%

D-

Freedom Index

63.2%

House

Judy Boyle

ID009

B-

Education Index

83.3%

D-

Freedom Index

60.4%

House

Mike Moyle

ID010

B-

Education Index

83.3%

Freedom Index

58.9%

House

Doug Pickett

ID027

Education Index

75.0%

Freedom Index

58.3%

House

James Holtzclaw

ID020

B-

Education Index

83.3%

Freedom Index

58.0%

Senate

Lori Den Hartog

ID022

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

56.7%

Senate

Todd Lakey

ID023

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

53.8%

House

John Vander Woude

ID022

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

52.8%

House

Wendy Horman

ID032

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

51.8%

House

Dori Healey

ID015

C+

Education Index

79.2%

Freedom Index

51.2%

House

Jeff Cornilles

ID012

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

49.7%

Senate

Ben Adams

ID012

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

49.7%

House

Lance Clow

ID025

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

48.2%

Senate

Scott Grow

ID014

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

46.5%

House

Steve Miller

ID024

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

45.7%

House

Melissa Durrant

ID023

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

45.1%

House

Megan Blanksma

ID008

D+

Education Index

66.7%

Freedom Index

44.8%

House

Marco Erickson

ID033

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

44.2%

Senate

Kelly Anthon

ID027

Education Index

85.7%

Freedom Index

43.6%

House

Matt Bundy

ID008

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

43.6%

House

Clay Handy

ID027

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

43.6%

House

Dustin Manwaring

ID029

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

43.6%

Senate

Doug Ricks

ID034

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

43.3%

House

Chris Allgood

ID011

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

43.2%

House

Mark Sauter

ID001

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

42.3%

Senate

Dave Lent

ID033

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

42.0%

House

James Petzke

ID021

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

41.7%

House

Britt Raybould

ID034

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

40.5%

House

Rod Furniss

ID031

Education Index

58.3%

Freedom Index

39.9%

House

Lori McCann

ID006

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

39.9%

House

Rick Cheatum

ID028

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

39.6%

House

Julie Yamamoto

ID011

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

39.3%

House

Jon Weber

ID034

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

39.3%

House

Jerald Raymond

ID031

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

39.3%

House

Kenny Wroten

ID013

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

38.6%

Senate

Julie VanOrden

ID030

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

38.2%

Senate

Treg Bernt

ID021

A-

Education Index

92.9%

Freedom Index

37.9%

House

Stephanie Mickelsen

ID032

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

37.7%

Senate

Mark Harris

ID035

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

37.6%

House

Dan Garner

ID028

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

36.8%

Senate

Van Burtenshaw

ID031

A-

Education Index

92.9%

Freedom Index

36.6%

House

Chenele Dixon

ID024

Education Index

41.7%

Freedom Index

36.5%

Senate

Jim Guthrie

ID028

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

36.3%

Senate

Kevin Cook

ID032

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

36.3%

Senate

Chuck Winder

ID020

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

35.7%

House

Greg Lanting

ID025

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

35.0%

House

Jack Nelsen

ID026

Education Index

45.8%

Freedom Index

31.3%

Senate

Abby Lee

ID009

Education Index

85.7%

Freedom Index

29.9%

Senate

Linda Hartgen

ID025

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

29.3%

House

Brooke Green

ID018

Education Index

25.0%

Freedom Index

23.3%

House

Soñia Galaviz

ID016

Education Index

25.0%

Freedom Index

20.2%

House

John Gannon

ID017

Education Index

25.0%

Freedom Index

20.2%

House

Ilana Rubel

ID018

Education Index

12.5%

Freedom Index

18.4%

House

Ned Burns

ID026

Education Index

16.7%

Freedom Index

16.0%

Opposed (15)

Senate

Dan Foreman

ID006

A+

Education Index

100.0%

A-

Freedom Index

91.1%

A+

Spending Index

100.0%

Senate

Geoff Schroeder

ID008

A+

Education Index

100.0%

Freedom Index

29.6%

Senate

Rick Just

ID015

Education Index

42.9%

Freedom Index

24.8%

Senate

James Ruchti

ID029

Education Index

57.1%

Freedom Index

24.8%

Senate

Janie Ward-Engelking

ID018

Education Index

57.1%

Freedom Index

24.5%

Senate

Ali Rabe

ID016

Education Index

42.9%

Freedom Index

21.3%

Senate

Carrie Semmelroth

ID017

Education Index

57.1%

Freedom Index

20.7%

Senate

Ron Taylor

ID026

C-

Education Index

71.4%

Freedom Index

20.4%

Senate

Melissa Wintrow

ID019

Education Index

28.6%

Freedom Index

20.4%

House

Sue Chew

ID017

Education Index

0.0%

Freedom Index

18.4%

House

Steve Berch

ID015

Education Index

16.7%

Freedom Index

18.1%

House

Chris Mathias

ID019

Education Index

33.3%

Freedom Index

17.8%

House

Lauren Necochea

ID019

Education Index

0.0%

Freedom Index

15.3%

House

Nate Roberts

ID029

Education Index

16.7%

Freedom Index

15.3%

House

Todd Achilles

ID016

Education Index

29.2%

Freedom Index

11.0%

Missed Vote (1)

House

Josh Wheeler

ID035

Education Index

50.0%

Freedom Index

41.4%

House Bill 601 would provide immunity from civil damages to volunteer security personnel of a religious organization so long as their actions do not constitute gross negligence or wanton or reckless misconduct.

Roll Call Vote (House)

Roll Call Vote (Senate)

Compare District

Last Action

Analysis

Supported (89)

Opposed (15)

Missed Vote (1)

Request your printed copies of the Idaho Freedom Index mailed to you!